Lucky star

Megan Griffiths talks about making Lucky Them.

by Anne-Katrin Titze

Thomas Haden Church as Charlie with Toni Collette as Ellie: "I think he just riffs on what's there. It's extended rather than shifted."
Thomas Haden Church as Charlie with Toni Collette as Ellie: "I think he just riffs on what's there. It's extended rather than shifted."

Following the Tribeca Talks: Pen to Paper - Adaptation & Creation panel with filmmakers Amy Berg, Adam Rapp, Stephen Belber and Megan Griffiths held at Barnes & Noble Union Square over Easter weekend, I spoke with Lucky Them director Griffiths about the mystery of her film. On the panel, she spoke about the roles Paul Newman and Joanne Woodward played in the making of her film.

Lucky Them director Megan Griffiths.
Lucky Them director Megan Griffiths. Photo: Anne-Katrin Titze

Thomas Haden Church steals the show in Megan Griffiths' spirited comedy set in the world of Seattle music journalism and hankering for love stories past. Based in part on adventures in co-screenwriter Emily Wachtel's life, Toni Collette plays music journalist Ellie Klug who likes her whiskey straight and her life uncomplicated. The magazine she works for is in trouble and her boss Giles (Oliver Platt) forces Ellie to write about the famous musician Matthew Smith who mysteriously disappeared many years ago and also happened to be her ex- boyfriend.

Anne-Katrin Titze: You have a most unusual detective team in your film.

Megan Griffiths: We definitely wanted to play up this following a mystery and they are such inept detectives. Only by a sort of strike of inspiration does she ever figure it out. They are not really on the right track ever. They were funny to watch that way.

AKT: I interviewed Thomas Haden Church last year at Tribeca for Whitewash, where he was fantastic. You said in your film he changed some of the dialogue?

MG: I think he just riffs on what's there. It's extended rather than shifted. He started with the kernel that was in the script and then extended it outward into something that was much more interesting and layered and unique and strange.

Thomas Haden Church steals the show in Griffiths' spirited comedy set in the world of Seattle music journalism.
Thomas Haden Church steals the show in Griffiths' spirited comedy set in the world of Seattle music journalism. Photo: Anne-Katrin Titze

AKT: "I hate music - all music" was one of the best lines and believable.

Charlie (Haden Church) accompanies Ellie (Collette) into her grungy past, which isn't easy for him because he hates music, "all music." With only three minutes of footage and a lot of dead ends, including a Galago night monkey wedding gift surprise, the unlikely detective team keeps looking for a reclusive past that withdraws from being found.

MG: That actually was in the script. he has a moment where he is writing down something. And he says "there is a crispness to my writing that I enjoy". That's all him.

AKT: In Whitewash he had wonderful scenes in which he shoved food in his coat pockets very elegantly. Will all of the actors be here for the red carpet on Monday at the BMCC?

Griffiths enjoys showing us the particulars of Ellie's life and it doesn't feel like exposition though it might look a little ersatz. She lives in an apartment filled with albums and a creepy guy breaks up with her after three month of too casual an involvement, for his taste, so he says. When she hears Lucas (Ryan Eggold) playing his music on the street, he looks just right to be her next conquest and she throws her business card in his hat.

MG: Everybody's here. Toni [Collette], Tom [Haden Church], Oliver Platt, Ryan Eggold and Nina Arianda. We're doing a red carpet and then they'll be there for a Q&A.

Tribeca Film Festival public screenings: April 21, 9:30pm – BMCC; April 23, 9:30pm – SVA Theater 1; April 26, 12:00pm – Bow Tie Cinemas Chelsea

Share this with others on...
News

The division belle Suzannah Herbert on facing the US' troubled history and making Natchez

Spin-off alchemy Claude Schmitz on bringing back cop pairing for Conrad & Crab – Idiotic Gems

Past crime Christoffer Boe on creating a world for his period mystery Special Unit - The First Murder

The hidden river Helen MacDonald and Philippa Lowthorpe on adapting H Is For Hawk

This wild channel David Shadrack Smith and Jake Fogelnest on the content creation revolution and Public Access

Sundance announces winners Josephine, Nuisance Bear, Shame And Money and To Hold A Mountain take top prizes

More news and features

Interact

As we move into 2026, don't forget that you can follow us on YouTube for trailers of festival films and more. You can also find us on Mastodon and Bluesky.

With awards season in full flow, you can keep track of the latest news on that here:

César nominations Nouvelle Vague leads the race for France's biggest awards

BAFTA nominations One Battle After Another and Sinners almost neck and neck

Golden Eddies Nominations for editing brilliance announced

OFCS Awards One Battle After Another triumphs; Sinners dominates