Eye For Books

A fresh look at Edison's Frankenstein

by Jennie Kermode

packshot
Edison's Frankenstein by Frederick C Wiebel Jr, Bear Manor Media, ISBN-10: 1593935153, $24.95

When early filmmakers undertook their strange experiments with cameras, lights and action, did they have any idea what their experiments would lead to? It seems a fitting thing to look at early cinema through the lens of Mary Shelley's cautionary yet ambitious tale, and Frederick Wiebel's take on the 1910 version of Frankenstein is fascinating - not least so because the film, too, was once nothing more than a collection of scattered parts, painstakingly reassembled and restored to life.

This is a slow time of year for books on film. Most of those sent to us here at Eye For Film have been written primarily to provide entertainment, so they're often fun but won't often amuse you for more than a few hours. Wiebel's work is something you'll find yourself returning to again and again, and is no less entertaining for it. It's a great piece of journalism, extraordinarily thorough, taking an approach to its subject matter that mirrors the mystery at its core. There are also lots of illustrations which will intrigue history-lovers, though due to the age of the originals the quality is often poor.

Does the film deserve such devotion? Here one might hesitate. It is, after all, less that 15 minutes long, and it doesn't stand up all that well alongside other works of the period, for all its significance as an early entry in the horror canon. In itself it's rather a slight thing around which to frame such a complex narrative, but Wiebel uses it as the starting point for an exploration of cinematic development which is full of insights about changing technologies and industry attitudes. This means that it's well worth a read pretty much no matter what you think of the film itself. And whilst not everyone will see Frankenstein as a great piece of art, it was undeniably significant for the film industry. Screening all over the US, it might be considered one of the first ever blockbusters, a film made with the intention of entertaining, chilling and thrilling in equal measure.

Few books about cinema pack in as much information as this one. For fans of the film, it's a must read, whilst others will find it an intriguing curiosity.

Share this with others on...
News

Family reunion Tasha Hubbard on exploring the aftermath of the Sixties Scoop in Meadowlarks

Throwback Adam Rehmeier on the spirit of Seventies cinema and Carolina Caroline

Uncovering everyday moments Alvin Hall and Sam Pollard on uncovering the history of The Lorraine

Driven by love and capitalism Director Pierre Le Gall on the themes of Flesh and Fuel

The ultimate act of friendship Robin Campillo on picking up the threads from the late Laurent Cantet

Reaching for a better future Daniel E Catullo, Julie DeVercelly and Gary DeVercelly on hazing and 4000 Days

More news and features

We're bringing you news, reviews and more from ImagineNative and Tribeca.



We're looking forward to Docs Ireland and the Fantasia International Film Festival.



We've recently brought you coverage of Cannes, Queer East, the San Francisco Independent Film Festival, Visions du Réel, Fantaspoa, Overlook, BFI Flare and SXSW, the Thessaloniki International Documentary Festival and the NY Rendezvous with French Cinema.



Read our full for more.


Visit our festivals section.

Interact

Don't forget that you can follow us on YouTube for trailers of festival films and more. You can also find us on Mastodon and Bluesky.


It's a busy time for festivals and here's the latest:


Fantasia Second wave of titles announced


Tribeca Artistic director Frédéric Boyer discusses the highlights of this year's edition


Cannes The 2026 Palme d'Or has gone to Fjord


Cannes Everytime wins Un Certain Regard prize


Cannes Yuri wins Palm Dog for La Perra


Cannes La Gradiva tops Critics' Week awards