Critics criticised for film failures

Johnny Depp and Ashton Kutcher get angry.

by Jennie Kermode

Johnny Depp has spoken out this week about the poor box office returns for The Lone Ranger, blaming critics for its lack of success and accusing them of hating it before they even saw it. Meanwhile, Ashton Kutcher has complained that he has been attacked for his potrayal of Apple guru Steve Jobs even in the early stages of production, being told that his costume is wrong.

Can critics make or break a film? Several pieces of research have shown a strong correlation between ratings on meta-review sites like Rotten Tomatoes and the box office success of major releases, but it's difficult to say if this is because critics influence the public's attitude to films or if it's simply that better films are more successful. One interesting piece of research by Alec Kennedy shows that reviews have a stronger correlation with a film's staying power than with its initial box office success, probably because early reviews struggle to be noticed past marketing hype. As The Lone Ranger has only been out for two weeks in the US (it opens in the UK on Friday) this suggests that it's too early for the impact of reviews to be measured.

According to Disney, The Lone Ranger is expected to lose between £104M and £124M. Most major films rely on their opening weekend to make most of their money, though things can work differently for smaller, more unusual films with staying power. These days, success in the Chinese market is a key factor, with the success of Pacific Rim there virtually guaranteeing that film a sequel. The Lone Ranger, however, has yet to secure a Chinese release date.

Share this with others on...

Movies out this week include:

The Aeronauts The Irishman Meeting Gorbachev

Keeping his word Michael Apted in conversation on 63 Up

Talking about juxtapositions Thom Powers on dreams, fashion, identity, nature and bright spotlights in DOC NYC

Dedicated to DA Pennebaker Thom Powers on Martin Scorsese, Michael Apted, the Masters and Winner’s Circle in the tenth edition

Free to become someone else Costume designers Ann Roth and Carlo Poggioli on The English Patient

Faith in humanity Robert Budina and Arben Bajraktaraj talk about a Shelter Among The Clouds

Tallinn to honour Andrei Konchalovsky Russian director to receive lifetime achievement award

More news and features

We're bring you coverage of the London Korean Film Festival and DOC NYC and the French Film Festival.

We're looking forward to Tallinn Black Nights and Welsh horror festival Abertoir.

We've recently been at the Valencia Film Festival, New York's NewFest, the Cambridge Film Festival, the New York Film Festival, the London Film Festival, the Iris Prize Festival in Cardiff, Manchester's Grimmfest, the Scottish Queer International Film Festival and the San Sebastian Film Festival.

Read our full for more.

Visit our festivals section.


More competitions coming soon.