Eye For Film >> Movies >> The Secret In Their Eyes (2009) 4K Blu-Ray Review
The Secret In Their Eyes
Reviewed by: Amber Wilkinson
Read Amber Wilkinson's film review of The Secret In Their Eyes
Juan José Campanella’s Oscar winner is getting a bumper limited edition presentation from Second Sight Films on November 23 as well as a standard edition release. It's dual format UHD and Blu-ray.
The best of the extras involve the director himself, particularly the audio commentary from Campanella which first appeared on discs back in 2010. In it, he digs into the anatomy of his filmmaking, especially the dominant “two tones” he used in his colour palette. He also highlights the extensive use of VFX in the films, which extends far beyond its breathtaking football stadium zoom in.
He often discusses his decisions as he might a piece of music, talking about overtures and the like, making this a very accessible, as well as interesting companion piece which indicates how flexible he is as a director and alive to the possibility of changing things on the spot. There’s a new interview with him that has the added virtue of him being able to talk about the film and its journey in full retrospect. Snippets of enjoyable detail across these two features include observations about the stars’ onscreen chemistry despite not being particularly close in real life, the use of very slight Dutch angles, and the employment of, at the time cutting edge, RED cameras.
The second, new, audio commentary with academics Gizella Meneses and Dave Park is less successful, mainly because they fall into the trap of talking about what the film is doing – which we can already see – too much, rather than digging deeper into the backdrop. There’s also considerable hesitant umming and ahhing, which could have done with a strong edit.
Decoding the Mystery: Joe Lipsett on The Secret in Their Eyes is a new video essay, which is interesting for the most part, although again there doesn’t seem to have been much of an editorial pass. Most notably, he describes the stadium scene as “infamous” rather than “famous”, which sticks out like a sore thumb unless I missed a whole news story about that being held up as a disgrace at some point.
The other new material is engaging. An interview with producers Mariela Besuievsky and Gerardo Herrero offers a different perspective on the project, while a chat with composers Emilio Kauderer and Federico Jusid gives plenty of insight into their working relationship in addition to their collaboration on the film itself.
A Making Of – the only extra which involves the cast of the film – is also carried over from previous releases and offers an enjoyable backstage perspective. It’s a lot more interesting that the dull Hollywood talking heads extras that are often included under this sort of title.
The film looks and sounds sharp, the colour work discussed by Campanella can be enjoyed. In fact, it’s so good in terms of detail, it’s hard for ageing make-up from the period to stand up to the scrutiny in places, although it speaks volumes to the director’s skill that he knew exactly when to keep the light low.
The special edition also features a 120-page book with new essays by Rob Hunter, Tom Phelan, Andrew Pope, Shelagh Rowan-Legg, Gabriel Eljaiek Rodriguez and Nadine Whitney and six collectors' art cards, which were not included with the review set.
Reviewed on: 17 Nov 2026