Effortless style is a something that is highly prized in film, and thankfully many films get
the proverbial smoke in the bottle rather easily. It is quite different when the film is classy
without really
trying. Samuel Fuller's Pickup on South Street is one such noir. Let me illustrate.
The chief of police, Captain Dan Tiger, is talking with a government agent about petty
crook Skip McCoy, a three-time convict and pickpocket who has picked the wrong purse.
Agent : "I'm looking for a pickpocket."
Tiger : "What's his name?"
Agent : "Don't know"
Tiger (almost immediately, while lighting a cigarette): "We're in trouble."
*a short beat*
Tiger : "You know what he looks like?"
Agent : "Mm-hmm"
*another short beat with a blast of cigarette smoke*
Tiger : "We're in business"
He then, without turning his body or head, flicks open the filing cabinet, and without really
looking in, grabs a handful of mugshots.
It is the hard-boiled simplistic delivery and effortless half-grace that I love so much about
film noir. There are other ingredients, but it's the direct and straightforward writing and
performing that I enjoy most.
The purse that McCoy picked contains the quintessential McGuffin, government secrets
on microfilm, and the courier, the potential femme fatale, is unknowingly working for the
Communists. They're represented in the film as characters who say little and drive some
inhuman gravitas around the chief villain of the piece. I enjoy the use of the Communist
regime as the means for driving some kind of faceless, thick evil into the film, a
manipulative message from capitalism which resonated strongly with most of the 1953
audience.
Why do I enjoy it so? Simply because it's such an obvious and fun play by the filmmakers
to drive a chill down the spine of its intended audience. It doesn't work so well nowadays,
what with the current American political climate and media-savvy viewers, but it's not
difficult for a modern audience to get the point. The microfilm is hidden in a pleasingly
primitive icebox of beer, substituted and replaced with a copy of the January 5, 1947
edition of the New York Times thanks to the New York Public Library. (If any reader cares
to explain the significance of this, feel free.)
Both sides are helped and hindered by another fruity and delightful character, Moe,
played by Rear Window's Thelma Ritter. A professional and wily stool-pigeon
who sells cheap ties as her cover, she interrogates the government agent in the methods
and techniques of pickpockets, and argues her price. "The price of living has gone up 50
per cent," she complains bitterly. She also gets her moment of dramatic weight, as the
EvilBastardCommies try to recover the stolen film. The courier attempts to get the
microfilm back off McCoy, and they end up falling in love, although several plotpoints
keep them off each other's bones.
One area in which the film is innovative is the editing, creating tension in the scenes of
pickpocketing. Fuller directs as though McCoy was painting a work of art, so slowly, and
lovingly, his camera captures the action. Another masterful set of edits using faces
happens when the agents are tailing the courier. The close-up tailing and chase editing
techniques were reused to similar effect in Scorsese's recent
The Departed. Another episode like this occurs when the villain meets with the
EvilBastardCommies and through this a scene of impending, palpable doom plays out
through eyes and faces half-bathed in shadow.
As a piece of noir, Pickup on South Street is successful. Three lightweight criminals
without a drop of real heroics, dark shadowy photography where there isn't a drop of real
white in the film stock, only shades of gray, like the character's motivations, the period
Forties fedoras, and of course the tough and gorgeous hard-boiled writing.